Metal Roofing in Oklahoma vs Shingles: What We Recommend

Red River Roofing crew member and homeowner looking up at the shingle roof of a brick home during a no-cost roof inspection

Metal roofing in Oklahoma draws plenty of interest when it’s time for a new roof. It can last for decades, and it looks sharp.

Red River Roofing, Siding, and Windows has served Oklahoma homeowners for 27 years and installs both metal and shingle roofs. For most homes, though, we recommend impact-resistant shingles.

This guide covers how the two compare on hail damage, insurance, and cost, and what we’d put on your roof instead. If you want a recommendation for your own house, every estimate starts with a no-cost inspection.

How hail affects metal roofing in Oklahoma

A larger share of Oklahoma roofs get hit by severe hail than in any other state. The Oklahoma Insurance Department, citing a Verisk report, puts the figure at 49.7% over the last four years. Hail is a big part of why we recommend shingles.

Hail damages the two materials in different ways. A shingle loses protective granules or cracks in the layer underneath, and then it can’t shed water the way it should. A metal panel dents. The roof often keeps shedding water, but it no longer looks the way it did.

Illustration of hail damage on an asphalt shingle next to a dented metal roofing panel, with notes on insurance treatment

Many metal roofs carry a Class 4 impact rating, the highest rating, and they can still dent like the panel above. The rating comes from a lab test (UL 2218) that drops steel balls onto the roofing and checks whether it cracks or leaks. It doesn’t measure dents.

Whether your insurer pays for those dents is a separate question.

Metal roofing and insurance in Oklahoma

The wording in your policy matters. A recent Oklahoma federal case quoted one policy that defined cosmetic damage as damage that only changes how the roof looks, without letting water in or keeping the roof from doing its job. When an insurer calls hail dents cosmetic, you may end up paying for them yourself. Insurance attorneys have written up that case.

Look for the word “cosmetic” in your policy, or ask your agent to find the language for you.

Insurers also reward some roof upgrades. A FORTIFIED roof may qualify for an insurance discount, and the amount depends on your insurer. FORTIFIED is a storm standard from the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS). It covers more than the shingles, including the roof deck (the wood layer under the roofing), roof edges, and attic vents.

The Oklahoma Insurance Department’s Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program offers grants of up to $10,000 toward a FORTIFIED roof. Grants go to qualifying homeowners while funds last, and the requirements include a homestead exemption on file with your county. Ask your agent about discounts before you apply.

FORTIFIED works with other roof covers too, including metal. Each cover has its own testing requirements.

Questions to ask your insurance agent

  1. Does my policy exclude cosmetic roof damage?

  2. Which roofing materials earn a discount?

  3. What is my wind and hail deductible?

If hail has already hit your roof, our insurance claims page covers how we help with the process. If you’re not sure what your roof needs, schedule a no-cost roof inspection and we’ll walk you through it.

What drives the cost of metal roofing in Oklahoma

Metal roofing costs more up front than shingles. Beyond that, no two roofs cost the same. Roof size, pitch, and shape all change the price, and so does whatever we find under the old roof once it comes off. Our guide to roof replacement costs in Oklahoma shows general ranges by material, but a range can’t account for your roof.

Lifespan is the usual reason to pay more for metal roofing. A metal roof can outlast shingles if hail doesn’t get to it first, and in Oklahoma that’s a big if. The long life only counts if the roof is doing its job after the storms in between, and if your insurer pays when it isn’t.

Because every roof is different, estimates come after the inspection. That inspection is the start of your Home Treatment Plan. Your account manager asks what’s going on, looks closely at whatever brought you to call, and then walks the rest of the house. That’s a 360 exterior evaluation of the roofing, siding, windows, and other visible exterior components, plus a check of the attic.

Afterward, we send you the plan in writing. It shows what looks good and what needs attention, and it separates what to handle now from what can wait, based on your timing and budget. Any estimate comes from that plan. If cost is a concern, ask us about financing options.

Shingles vs metal roofing at a glance

Shingles vs Metal Roofing At a Glance Infographic

What we recommend instead of metal roofing

For most Oklahoma homes, we recommend a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle roof. What goes under and around the shingles matters just as much.

  • A shingle with a top hail rating. Class 4 is the starting point. IBHS says shingles that rate Good or Excellent outperform typical Class 4 shingles against realistic hailstones, so ask for that rating too.

  • A sealed roof deck and stronger roof edges. Sealing the seams in the roof deck helps keep water out if wind rips shingles off.

  • An attic that moves air. When intake and exhaust vents are out of balance, heat and moisture get trapped under the roof deck, and the shingles lose their granules faster. Red River Roofing, Siding, and Windows is one of a small number of Oklahoma contractors with ventilation expertise, and we check the attic on every inspection.

Your Home Treatment Plan shows which of these your house needs. Sometimes the answer is a repair, or no work for now.

Our roof type comparison guide lists the Class 4 shingles we install. Our residential roofing page covers the manufacturer certifications behind our work.

When metal roofing makes sense

Metal is a standard fit for porch covers, additions, and low-slope sections.

On a main roof, metal can make sense if you plan to stay in the house a long time. You should also confirm your policy covers dents, or be comfortable with the cosmetic risk.

Can you put metal roofing over existing shingles?

Sometimes, depending on local building codes. We usually advise removing the shingles first, so we can check the roof deck for rot and moisture before anything new goes on. Metal over shingles saves time up front, but it can hide problems underneath. Our post on installing a metal roof over existing shingles covers the risks.

Common questions about metal roofing in Oklahoma

Is metal roofing worth it in Oklahoma?

It can be, if you plan to stay in the house a long time and your insurance covers dents. For most homes, we recommend impact-resistant shingles instead.

Does metal roofing hold up to hail in Oklahoma?

A Class 4 metal roof is built not to crack or leak under hail, but it can still dent. Whether the dents matter depends on your policy and on how much the look of the roof matters to you.

Does insurance cover hail damage on a metal roof?

That depends on your policy. Some carry a cosmetic damage exclusion, which means the insurer won’t pay for damage that only changes how the roof looks. Ask your agent for the exact language.

Does metal roofing lower your insurance in Oklahoma?

Some insurers discount impact-rated roofing, and the amount depends on the carrier and the roof. Ask your agent which materials qualify before you buy.

How much does metal roofing cost in Oklahoma?

It depends on the roof. Size, pitch, roof shape, and what’s under the old layer all change the price, so we don’t give a firm number without seeing the house. Your estimate comes from the Home Treatment Plan we build during a no-cost inspection. For general ranges by material, see our guide to roof replacement costs in Oklahoma.

Schedule a no-cost roof inspection

If you’re weighing metal roofing in Oklahoma, an inspection is the fastest way to find out what your roof needs. Your account manager walks the house, checks the attic, and sends you the Home Treatment Plan in writing. If it isn’t time to replace, we’ll say so.

Schedule your no-cost inspection

Next
Next

Window Replacement Cost in Oklahoma: What’s in Your Quote